The US Turns To Other Countries For Ed Reform

by TeachThought Staff

So the United States wants some more ed reform to add to the ed reform already in place, and to do so they’ve created a committee.

This committee–the The National Conference of State Legislatures–is seeking to “improve education.”

That this is vague and does’t even begin to imply the nature and utility of knowledge and continues our pattern thinking of teaching and learning as a kind of industries is a challenge to overcome.

Another challenge? To make this happen, they are turning to other countries, continuing America’s fascination with the Finland’s and Singapore’s of the world.

Within these other countries, they are then talking to policymakers–policy and initiative and program and committee among the language that reflects the tone of this commendable but perhaps wrong-headed effort. The guiding questions they’re using as they spearhead the effort do seem broad enough to allow for room for this effort to justify all the globe-trotting.

You can read the press release below.

Denver, Colo. — State legislators play an integral role in improving education and they consistently strive to learn more about how to advance high student achievement in the United States.

But state legislators are also very aware that despite decades of reform, the United States does poorly on education achievement when compared to other countries. The National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL) has undertaken an in-depth look at the education reform agendas and strategies of other countries to explore potential systematic ways education can be improved in the United States.

NCSL appointed a bipartisan study group of 28 legislators and six legislative staff members who have expertise, experience and interest in this topic. The study group held its first meeting in early September 2014 and a second meeting in December. The group has been studying with some of the top national and international experts, conducting research to better understand strategies and circumstances of the top performing countries, and discussing general themes emerging that can be important for states. The Study Group is working closely with Marc Tucker and staff at the National Center on Education and the Economy in this effort.

During this study, state legislators and legislative staff will identify strategies that have worked in other countries and that have the potential to also work in the states. Study group members recently returned from a two-week trip to China. During visits to Beijing and Shanghai, the group toured schools and met with scholars and Chinese officials to learn about education policy and initiatives in China.

“Many high-performing countries, especially Asian countries, have a long history of values and traditions rooted in education,” said Senator Luther Olsen, Wisconsin Senate Education Committee Chair.  “Although the United States has a different history and culture, there are common fundamental principles that top-performing countries have employed in their reform strategies, which may be relevant across our country and within individual states.”

5 Guiding Questions 

The study group plans to explore several questions, including:

What is working in other countries and why?

What can states learn from these experiences?

What is unique to these countries?

What fundamental principles support reform in successful countries and are relevant for states?

What are opportunities and roadblocks for states in pursuing education reform?

“In the high performing countries, the balance in the respective authorities of the central government and the local governments is an extremely important piece of the puzzle,” said Rep. Sharon Tomiko Santos, the Washington State House Education Chair.  “As Congress resumes consideration of the ESEA reauthorization, the Study Group hopes to share what we have learned about how our federal-state relationships can better support improved education outcomes for all students.”

The NCSL Study Group is in the process of planning other educational trips and opportunities to meet with reformers and implementers of reform in countries such as Singapore, Finland, Canada and Poland.

For more information about the NCSL Study Group on International Education, please contact Julie Davis Bell, NCSL’s Education Group Director at [email protected]; image attribution flickr user togawanderings